Data Centers, AI, Load Growth, Affordability… Oh My!

Episode 1 | Part 1

What Keeps Utility Professionals Up at Night?

Episode Transcript

GridGab | Ep. 1, Part I

00:00:00 Brad Langley: All right. Thank you, gentlemen, for taking the time. Um, and for being participants in our inaugural episode of Grid Gab. Where we get the opportunity to chat with some of grid sharpest people. Uh, and let them gab about what’s happening in our ever changing industry. Uh, as you guys all know, the grid is evolving at an incredibly fast rate, creating a seemingly endless amount of important topics to discuss. Uh, so thank you, Grant, Matt and Jim for joining me today. Uh, let’s go ahead and jump right in. Um, no script, no slides. Uh, just what’s hopefully a candid conversation, uh, between people who love to geek out on these topics, maybe some more so than others. Um, but yeah, let’s, uh, let’s get into it.

00:00:45 Brad Langley: Um, so kind of set the stage here a little bit. The massive amount of new load growth, emergence of complex rates, rising energy bills across the country. Uh, and emerging technologies are creating lots of questions for utilities and the companies like grid X that work with them. So let’s start with the state of the industry today. Uh, you all are on calls every day with utility professionals that power our daily lives. You know, the pressure they are under and the pace of change they are dealing with. Uh, what’s keeping them up at night? If you could choose just one thing. What’s causing restless sleep? Uh, Matt, let’s start with you.

00:01:28 Matt Ross: Yeah. I think, you know, there’s a lot of really salient issues with affordability and load growth and AI. So I think the utility, you know, stakeholders, execs so forth are really trying to, um, you know, address those kind of long term challenges, these like big rocks out there while focusing on the here and now, which is really tough place to be where you have affordability issues today. And they were here yesterday as well. So trying to mitigate that with kind of what you have in terms of your current capabilities or current offerings, while saying we really need to change as an industry. We’re at a a historic inflection point. Uh, you know, balancing those two at the same time is really hard because do you want to get the savings down the road or do you want them now? Maybe those are in conflict. Maybe you can find, you know, overlaps, but it’s, you know, people are really wrestling with, uh, today’s challenges and trying to get ahead for tomorrow.

00:02:33 Brad Langley: Grant, how about you?

00:02:35 Grant Reynolds: Yeah. I mean, I might just expand on what Matt said a bit. It’s just that, uh, the way I hear people view it, at least at the executive level, is like the utility ecosystem is its own beast. It’s dealing with technology, it’s dealing with regulatory worlds. It’s dealing with rates, affordability, all, all the things Matt was describing. And that’s one approach. They look at it like, do you change the utility ecosystem? Do you just change our relationship with having electricity, or do you go into the minutia of dealing with, okay, I’m in my utility, I have my systems, I have my issues, I have my affordability crisis, I have my things that are coming on my grid and, you know, going back, back and forth between those, you know, how do you how do you actually find the right percentage to, you know, of, of putting your firepower at each of those two problems?

00:03:23 Brad Langley: And Jim, you want to round this out?

00:03:24 Jim Pearce: Uh, for me, it’s really about what, uh, and also many utilities have talked about, like, how does this affect the ratepayer? Uh, so is there going to be an increase in bills, uh, in the cost of bills for utilities? Uh, it’s, it’s really difficult to, um, like keep costs down, especially with this massive growth and load where you need to invest in the infrastructure, which costs money. Uh, but how do you do that in a way that is equitable and prevents, uh, some of the more vulnerable populations from having to pay more, uh, when they’re already struggling.

00:04:13 Brad Langley: that affordability piece is a good jumping point to the next question. And Matt, I’m going to start with you here. Uh, yeah, I’ve heard you make the point through podcasts and written content that affordability has to come first, that we can’t build a sustainable future on unaffordable bills. Can you elaborate on what you mean by that?

00:04:32 Matt Ross: Yeah, I think you’re seeing, you know, policy shift in that direction. And and I agree with it to be frank. Um, we need to help customers manage their bills. Um, you know, and utilities aren’t the only, you know, group or industry that’s seeing rising costs. Um, there are ways to do that, you know, sustainably and in a more, uh, lower carbon approach. Um, but that’s going to always be secondary. And you’re seeing that, you know, in like states like new Jersey and Virginia. Um, and so it’s about finding the lowest cost solution. It’s about looking at your options holistically and often renewables or solar plus batteries become the, the best solution. Um, but it’s, you know, it is going to lead with the lowest cost, uh, approach, um, overall. And, you know, part of what we need to change is the grid is really kind of hardwired for centralized generation. And some of the cheapest resources on paper are decentralized. And so can you move in that direction where maybe the price per kWh is cheaper for those renewables, but the infrastructure isn’t really ready to take that bidirectional flow? Um, so I think those are some of the big things we need to change. I do think we can have our cake and eat it too, but we got to lead with affordability. Uh, as, as first and foremost.

00:06:10 Brad Langley: I feel like four or five years ago, net zero was the topic du jour. And everybody, every utility was kind of creating these net zero plans to get carbon neutral by twenty thirty. But twenty forty, you know, that’s still hanging out there, but it doesn’t seem to be at the forefront of a lot of utility objectives. Now, is that what you guys are seeing too?

00:06:31 Brad Langley: Like, is that a is that a recognition that affordability is number one, or are these utilities still striving for net zero goals?

00:06:41 Jim Pearce: Um, at least for me, it’s been just how to fill the gap in the load growth of like the demand versus the supply. The nice thing is I think we’re going to get there no matter what. Um, I mean, solar is just such it’s been adopted so widely. Um, and we really need those renewable energy sources just because we really can’t keep up, uh, using just coal and gas where I, I think that’s going to be something that happens as sort of a happy side effect. So I feel like we’re going to get there in both ways. It might take a while. Um, but that’s just my point of view. Grant. Matt, I don’t know if you had any differing points.

00:07:27 Grant Reynolds: Yeah, I mean, I mean, yeah, I think it’s, I, I’ve seen a less emphasis on it. I agree, Brad, that you heard, you know, was plastered everywhere on every website news article like five or six years ago. And now with vertical load demand or load demand going vertical, you know, how do you retire coal and coal power plants? You know, I mean, there’s it’s still happening, but, you know, it’s going to it’s going to come as a side effect, I think, in the future. But I think the the stress has to be on affordability or, you know, affordability plus climate, um, which obviously goes into the net zero, but throwing numbers out there on an industry that we just have no idea how it’s going to shape. I mean, we know, we know the load is coming, but we know there’s going to be more problems for the grid as it gets more complex as we have just more and more load. So and more and more electrification. So yeah, it it’ll be a net net effect, but it’s not the emphasis in my mind anymore.

00:08:22 Brad Langley: So with that uncertainty and we’ve seen projections that kind of vary wildly, making me wonder if we know fully just how significant of an issue this is. So Grant, you know, when the topic of affordability comes up, you know?

00:08:37 Brad Langley: What does that look like for utility executives sitting down with their rates and customer teams right now? What’s the conversation they’re having?

00:08:46 Grant Reynolds: Well, I think everyone has a little bit of a different conversation, which is which is part of the problem. Um, you know, I would, I would say that the before we have like a really robust, meaningful affordability conversation at utility, maybe some utilities are doing this. You really have to get a bunch of different stakeholders, you know, working the same vocabulary or at least kind of understanding people’s worlds that they have no idea about, right? You got to get regular regulatory people or rates at utilities working with the distribution or grid controllers a little bit. You got to get everyone kind of talking so that they can have, you know, kind of see the common vision. And then that’s, that’s one side of the coin. The other side of the coin is how do you actually have, you know, to throw in a little bit of a grit X pitch? How do you actually have like the actual tools or software systems to have the answers. Each of those groups need to exchange to each other as they come up. Well, if this is, you know, I want to go with X load increase, that means this load. That means this rate increase. Or we’d have to put this rate case in and pitch this to the regulator. Okay, well let’s tweak that a little bit. You go back to the drawing board each time. So if you don’t have both the minds of these people at utilities and the data systems or analytics systems that they get to own kind of being cohesive and talking, you’re really going to, you’re really going to struggle with, with tackling the affordability problem with good enough foresight, you know, because we don’t know what it’s five years, three years, it’s going to change. A good rate is changing almost every day what it even means for rate to be good. So yeah.

00:10:17 Jim Pearce: And I, I also wanted to expand upon something that you commented on, Brad, which was the uncertainty there. Um, there is a good amount of uncertainty in how large, uh, these loads will grow. Um, there’s a lot of numbers that vary and a grid built for, you know, uh, let’s say a few hundred gigawatt hours or gigawatts versus like many hundreds, like four hundred, five hundred, six hundred. It’s very different and very different investment where, uh, you need to have some sort of cost protections in place, whether it’s through rates or otherwise to if, if, let’s say the AI boom turns into AI bust. Uh, you don’t want other ratepayers holding the bag. Um, and how to protect utilities and ratepayers, uh, from any investments they make and how to essentially keep those investments, uh, as something that those who are using it, like the AI data centers, uh, to only pay.

00:11:21 Brad Langley: So there’s that. There’s this age old stat that I think the industry’s been trotting out for like ten, fifteen years now that people think about their utility or their energy use for seven minutes a year. So how do you engage with them? You know, you couple that with the fact that multiple service providers, multiple bills, social media news, like, you know, there’s so many things clamoring for people’s attention. But in this age of affordability, I mean, people do really want to save on their energy bills. So, you know, Matt, how do we get their attention in 30s or less? Is it a channel? Is it a message? Is it a combination of those things? How would you advise utilities on how to grab the attention in 30s or less?

00:12:01 Matt Ross: Yeah, I think you need to tell customers what to do to lower their bills, give them their next best action. Um, you know, a client once told me, um, you know, customers don’t want to glean insights and that’s really stuck with me. So if you’re, you know, bombarding them with energy use graphs and other, you know, kind of things that we, we see across utility websites, sometimes they’re not going to know how to make heads or tails of that. And as you mentioned, uh, there’s a lot of other forces competing for their attention. So I think saying, you know, hey Brad, this is your best bet. Next best action to lower your bills. And this is the, the savings, whether that’s a rate change. Enrolling in this program or some efficiency options, you have to be direct and it has to be personalized. Has to utilize their own usage data. Um, and I think customers will be really thankful for that. You know, kind of ten to fifteen second, uh, you know, nugget of information that they can actually act on.

00:13:06 Grant Reynolds: And I’ll just chime in, you know, something I’ve seen is like meeting, meeting customer at their energy literacy level, you know, your solar customer is much more engaged with those charts versus your just your run of the mill residential customer. And how do you have a, a one complete my account experience or a bill or rate education that checks all those boxes of all those different flavors of customer and keeps everyone happy, if you can, with only that fifteen or 30s that you might have. You know, each month or for the year even.

00:13:39 Brad Langley: Um, grant kind of picking up on something that you had said, uh, about bringing the different facets of utility together. I think one of the perceptions and misperceptions has been that utilities often act in silos Uh, you know, the rates teams not talking to the program team, maybe they’re talking to the IT team, but each is kind of doing their own thing, has historically had their own goals. Are, are, are any of you seeing a movement towards breaking down those silos and getting these teams more cohesively together to address these challenges? And if so, what’s bringing them together?

00:14:18 Grant Reynolds: I mean, I mean, I think sometimes utilities are siloed and it’s not that they want to be, it’s just that their systems, their data systems, and the way they go about the regulatory framework or, or customer experience, my accounts, what our customer engagement is just has to be that way given the systems they have. So, you know, part of breaking it down is, is making it one cohesive system, whatever that might look like, or at least having inputs and outputs to a bunch of different systems that let them not be so siloed. Um, but yeah, I mean, it’s, it’s a struggle. I mean, you hear people talk at conferences and they pitch the broad good idea. And a bunch of utility people are listening, but they’re all in taking it to their own little world. And it’s really challenging to like, like I said, to speak, you know, to get a one one vocabulary across an entire utility is probably a nightmare exercise, but probably something that has to happen if you want to unblock some of those silos.

00:15:13 Matt Ross: And I think we need some kind of regulatory change or alignment because these teams have different goals. And that’s what really creates the silos. It’s not because they don’t want to talk to each other or don’t like each other. They just have different jobs. And so if you’re designing rates and you’re saying, well, this is the most cost effective, uh, cost reflective, equitable set of rates, and then no one enrolls Was. Is that the fault of the rate design or is it poor marketing? And so I’ve seen those silos, but I’ve also seen utilities build specific teams that bridge those gaps where the rate design and the marketing are hand in hand. And I’ve seen that be much more successful. Um, and when you trace that back, yes, those are progressive, you know, forward leaning utilities, but they also have a, you know, a different regulatory, uh, kind of climate where they’re being regulated to have rate education alongside, um, the, the general rate case where you just kind of making the math work on, on revenue recovery. It’s also saying, well, if we’re going to launch this time of use rate, how are we going to inform customers that exist? How are they going to be able to evaluate whether that option is, is, is best for them? Uh, I think that’s critical. And yes, utilities can do a lot of that organically, but it also needs to be at the regulatory level.

00:16:46 Brad Langley: Can it be done without regulatory intervention? I mean, as you describe that that just seems like sound business practice. Um even if the regulators do not enact those kinds of of rules, can utilities still kind of orient their business around higher level objectives at a programmatic level, from design to implementation to measurement?

00:17:14 Matt Ross: I think, I think yes, of course they can do that. And we’ve we’ve seen that. And if you believe in this rate structure and you don’t put the marketing behind it or the engagement behind it, it’s going to fall flat. So that should happen. It is happening. Um, I think, you know, one of the hard parts is, you know, the regulatory folks kind of set the, the budget they, you know, set what tools you can use because ultimately the customers, the ratepayer needs to pay for this. And so if you need, um, you know, rate engagement or you need to update your website or do some marketing campaigns, it does cost money and that needs to come from, you know, a budget that gets approved. So even despite the utilities best intentions, there needs to be that alignment that we, we need customers to be able to understand their costs. We need transparency, we need options. And that should be part of the kind of creation and maintenance of any sort of rate or program.

00:18:18 Grant Reynolds: I agree with Matt there, but at some point, I do think the the regulators, whether it’s the commission or the ISOs or, you know, you hear PJM in the news a ton in the last six months or so. At some point, the economics question or the rate question gets broad enough that the physics of the grid starts to really just be the meaningful thing you have to think and talk about. And that kind of goes in. The physics of the grid will dictate the affordability ultimately. Like it just will. Um, so yeah, I see it happening on a small scale. It can totally be contained within the utility. But yeah, there are the larger things like we are all one. I mean, there’s three grids in the US, but like, we are kind of all one, those utilities and those areas are, you know, under one kind of, you know, controlling unit.

00:19:07 Brad Langley: Affordability is, is often grounded in the context of serving low to moderate income customers. But, you know, as a guy that lives in California, you know, seems like bills are really going up across the country impacting all customer classes. I mean, some are obviously better able to withstand those increased costs, but bills are still going up. Um, if the assumption is bills aren’t going to go down, how can we at least keep them flat? And Jim, maybe let’s start with you.

00:19:36 Jim Pearce: Yeah. Um, so the, the challenge is costs are going up even at like generation side or even supporting infrastructure. So I would say having the costs remain flat is challenging. I think there are ways to keep the costs from going up much higher than they are right now, whether that’s being putting responsible, uh, thought into where you invest your money, whether it’s in the rate design and like going to what Matt talked about, like, what are the ways that you can get more out of the grid you have today? Like, what are the lowest cost, whether it’s behavioral of, uh, if you market rates in a way that incentivizes customers to reduce their load at times where there’s peak demand on the grid, then you don’t have to invest as much in the actual infrastructure. And there’s there are ways to save there where like, it allows customers to, uh, essentially keep their bills low while also being able to, uh, get by with what we have and like keep the costs down for all I would say. Besides that, there is also data centers where for data centers, that’s driving a lot of the, uh, increases in demand on the grid where there’s, uh, essentially data centers have grown from like, I think, you know, a couple percentage points down to up to almost like ten percent these days, uh, of total demand on the grid where it just, it didn’t exist before.

00:21:21 Jim Pearce: Uh, utilities are struggling to keep up with it, which is causing a increase for all other customers. So how to structure the rates for data centers to bear most of the brunt of that load, rather than having the day to day ratepayers, even low to moderate income, have to bear that responsibility.

00:21:47 Matt Ross: I’ll just add, I see kind of two things here. You know, optimizing customers current, you know, energy use is something you can do today. And that could just be through different rate options. When you have like one, let’s say residential flat rate, the only thing you can do is reduce your energy consumption, which is hard to do if you’re having more extreme weather and so forth. It’s really hard to move the needle there. But if there are other, you know, programs or rate options you can take advantage of and shift usage, you know, maybe you’re thinking about a electric vehicle or a heat pump because there’s other costs outside the utility industry that are stretching you.

00:22:31 Brad Langley: Data centers has come up a couple times, and I want to dig into that. But before I do, who’s got. So we talked about this idea of aligning objectives and goals within the utility, from designing the rate to implementing the rate, uh, marketing the rate to ensure successful. Who’s got a favorite utility story of someone that’s done this, right? Um, because it’s good to talk in theory, but maybe at a high level, what, what’s a favorite customer story? And what do they do that, uh, enabled them to be successful?

00:23:06 Matt Ross: I mean, I’ve talked about PSEG Long Island a couple times. I still think that’s a really good example where we were in the room with their rates team, as well as their marketing team and their customer team. So they just said no to silos. Um, and they had a really thoughtful marketing, you know, for different kind of, you know, groups. They have a diverse population, as most utilities do. So I thought that was really effective in how they designed the rate they went for a pilot. They had all this kind of different marketing, you know, on the website, they had videos, they had a they had a time of use mascot. It was really creative and kind of modern. They didn’t take for granted that people would actually listen or care about a time of use rate. And so that was really effective. And then they heavily studied those pilot results, and they tweaked the rate design based on customer feedback before they went into the time of use default. So the mandatory time of use. So to me they’re the the gold standard. And you know, they did have the benefit of learning from, you know, peers like, um, you know, PG and E and others. So they’re still the kind of the, the top that I’ve worked with in terms of being intentional and then actually getting the desired outcomes. It’s, it’s really hard to pull off. And they really did a great job.

00:24:33 Brad Langley: Here at grid X, we know the benefit of a good mascot. Shout out Desi. But yeah, I agree that creative element to really make it accessible to people is, is super helpful. Um, grant or Jim, any, uh, customer examples you guys want to call out?

00:24:51 Jim Pearce: I just, I mean, one, I, I haven’t really worked with them as much, even though grid X does Was a. Georgia Power recently released an article of essentially partnering with OpenAI. Um, and, you know, so they would be supplying load, uh, to OpenAI. But, uh, just in that article, there was a mention about what that would do to customer bills and it was actually going to decrease customer bills by fifteen dollars a month.

00:25:23 Jim Pearce: Um, of course those are projections, but I feel like that is the sort of narrative that we should be looking towards is how, how can, uh, utilities and data centers help, uh, ratepayers and not, uh, more of an adversarial relationship that we have today?

00:25:45 Grant Reynolds: I don’t have a specific story, but I think just to expand on what Matt and Jim said there, but like, well, maybe, maybe just Matt, but tweaking rates, I think is kind of a new concept or at least iterating a little quicker. You know, there there are pilot rates out there that are really cool. There are utilities with multiple residential rates with zero or very few customers on them for XYZ reason. Right. And I think just iterating because the grid’s iterating so fast and changing, just being able to change or at least revisit the rate after a little bit of insight or data comes in around how it’s performing, how people are enjoying it, what are the, you know, what are their bills doing on it? All of those things I think is really powerful.

Description

Load growth is arriving while bills are already rising, and the grid needs investment either way. Utility affordability now sits at the center of decisions your rate, grid and customer teams have to make for years ahead, against forecasts that keep moving.

In the first half of a two-part conversation, host Brad Langley asks three GridX experts what they hear from utilities every day: why affordability now leads, why silos come down to different goals, how to earn a customer’s attention and what it takes to keep bills flat. Part 2 turns to data centers.

Show Notes & Links

• Why affordability has moved ahead of other utility objectives
• Getting rates, regulatory and grid teams to work from one vocabulary
• Why customers want a next best action, not another usage chart
• What actually creates silos, and how some utilities pair rate design with marketing
• How rate options and peak pricing can slow bill growth
• How PSEG Long Island designed, piloted and refined its time-of-use rollout

Affordability as the Gatekeeper to the Energy Transition Guide

Featured Experts

Matt Ross

Matt Ross

GridX, VP of Delivery

Grant Reynolds

GridX, Solution Architect

Jim Pearce

GridX, Sr. Solution Architect

Brad Langley

Brad Langley

GridX, CMO & Host of the With Great Power Podcast

Background

I do think we can have our cake and eat it too, but we got to lead with affordability.

Matt Ross

VP of Delivery, GridX

More on the Conversation